Milnor Law PLLC

Practice · 01 / 10

SEC Enforcement Defense

Subpoena response, Wells notices, on-the-record interviews, settlement negotiation, and disgorgement defense for individuals and entities under Commission investigation.

← All practice areas

Senior representation at every stage of an SEC investigation, from the first subpoena or document request through the Wells process, settlement negotiation, or contested proceedings before the Commission. Also engaged when an examination produces a deficiency letter serious enough to signal an enforcement referral.

Senior representation through every stage of an SEC investigation, from the first subpoena or document request through Wells process, settlement negotiation, or contested proceedings before the Commission.

Scope of the work

An SEC investigation moves through stages, and early guidance can change where it ends. Christina advises targets and others drawn into an enforcement investigation, from the Matter Under Inquiry stage through a Formal Investigation. She prepares witnesses for on-the-record testimony and represents them at that testimony. When the staff issues a Wells notice, she handles the Wells process, including the submission that argues against a charging recommendation.

Each stage carries decision points, and Christina identifies them early, prepares for them deliberately, and works to keep them from becoming harder than they need to be. A document production that does not anticipate the staff’s follow-up questions invites a second request. An on-the-record interview without a clear theory of the matter invites a Wells notice. A Wells submission that argues for sympathy rather than engaging the staff’s actual concerns invites a charging recommendation.

When clients engage the firm

Clients typically come to the firm after receiving a subpoena, a Wells notice, a request for an on-the-record interview, or a notification that staff is recommending an enforcement action to the Commission. Some have prior counsel; many do not. Some have had limited contact with the staff; others have been in the matter for a year and are entering Wells process.

The first call is short, confidential, and subject to a conflict check. The goal of that conversation is to understand the posture, the timing, and whether the firm is the right fit. Engagements do not begin before a written engagement letter is signed and any required conflict checks are complete.

Approach to defense

Christina handles every meeting, draft, submission, and call. Strategy is set early, written down, and revisited as the matter develops. Settlement is treated from the outset as a serious option, while the firm also builds the record for closing the matter on the facts, the law, or the public-interest grounds the Commission weighs.

The timing of a Wells submission is set by the SEC. Submissions are read by the staff, reviewed by the Office of the General Counsel, and weighed by the Commissioners who vote on whether to authorize a case. A strong submission engages the staff's theory, addresses the cost-benefit analysis the Commission is required to consider, and offers a defensible factual record.

Parallel proceedings

SEC enforcement matters often arrive with more than one regulator involved. Common parallel tracks include a CFTC (Commodity Futures Trading Commission) investigation, a DOJ criminal investigation, an SRO disciplinary proceeding at FINRA or an exchange such as NYSE or Nasdaq, and civil class actions filed on the heels of any public disclosure of the SEC matter.

Disgorgement, civil penalties, statutory bars, suspensions, and Rule 102(e) undertakings are all addressed at the framing stage, not after the fact. Choices made in the SEC matter follow the client everywhere else. Testimony given to the staff can be used in a parallel criminal case, and because an SEC proceeding is civil, invoking the Fifth Amendment there can support an adverse inference against the client, a consequence the Constitution forbids in the criminal case itself. Whether a witness testifies, asserts the privilege, cooperates, or settles is therefore decided with every venue in view. The firm coordinates rather than compartmentalizes.